Value Design Ltd
  • Value Design Ltd
  • Services
  • Projects
  • Finite Element Analysis
    • Introduction to Basic FEA
    • Units
    • Co-ordinate Systems
    • FEA Procedure
    • Defining Objectives
    • Stress Concentration
    • Geometry import / clean up
    • Meshing
    • Material Properties
    • Boundary Conditions
    • Solvers
    • Investigating FEA Results
    • Reporting
    • Stress Theories
    • Cantilever Beam Worked Example
    • Pressure Vessel Worked Example
    • Shaft in Torsion Worked Example
    • Buckling Worked Example
    • Bearing (Contact) Worked Example
    • Non Linear Material Worked Example
    • Portal Frame Worked Example
  • BLOG
  • FAQ
    • What is FEA?
    • How much does FEA cost?
    • Should I de-feature CAD geometry prior to FEA?
    • What information should I send to you for an FEA quotation?
  • CONTACT

Blog

Categories

All
Boundary Conditions
FEA Tips And Tricks
Modal
News
Nonlinear
Oddball
Top Ten

Archives

May 2023
August 2022
May 2022
September 2021
August 2021
June 2021
February 2020

Top Ten Reasons Components Break

8/18/2021

3 Comments

 
Picture
There are so many reasons engineering components break, I've seen quite a few and here is my top ten list. There must be many others that I've missed. I've always said that the best way to learn about engineering and in particular finite element analysis, is to study components that have already broken.
1. Stress Concentrations
Now for ductile materials such as steel, this is of concern for durability but not for overall strength. However, brittle materials such as grey iron tend to crack in areas of high stress concentration even for single loading events.


​2. Weld Fractures
A lot of component failures are due to welding since no two welds are the same. Welds situated too close to each other, in the wrong place, the wrong size or of poor quality are the main culprits of failures.

3. Selecting the Wrong Material
Some people switch to a cheaper grade of material in an effort to reduce cost without revisiting the calculations or FEA. Some materials do not fare well when exposed to high or low temperatures, corrosive substances or high cyclic loading. 

4. Skipping FEA or Calculations to Save Time
Guessing component sizes is a tempting gamble to speed up the project and reduce initial development costs. A gamble that usually costs the project dear!

5. Using the Wrong Design Code and Standards
Treat mobile machinery like a building if you want but it will probably break. Buildings don’t move and they don’t bump into things. Don't use a building design code for cranes, use a crane code. Use the right design code!


6. Sweeping the Hard Load Cases Under the Carpet
Checking the easy load cases and ignoring the the difficult ones that really could break your components is more common than you think. It's nearly always the tricky load cases that are hard to define that are the main culprits for component failures. 

7. Stripping Out Too Much Material
Optimising your components for reduced weight to strip out excessive margins of safety is what all we all want.  Components often fail due to fault load cases that may not have been considered because they were unknown at the time. Leave a safety net!

8. Relying on a Single Load Path
Designing components with a single load path is asking for trouble! Hanging large weights on a single bolt or weld is never a good idea. Would you stand underneath it?

9. Poor Quality Control
Poor quality castings and incorrect heat treatment without proper quality control are prime suspects. There are lots of design codes and manufacturing standards that should be followed.
​
​10. Lack of Physical Testing
FEA Analysis and other CAE tools are great but to validate designs, some component testing is often still required. Skip this at your own risk!
There are lots of other reasons parts fail, I'm interested to hear of your experiences with component failures and what you did to fix it?
3 Comments
Linda Cole
8/24/2021 05:51:28 am

Nice article

Reply
Ramin
9/1/2021 06:52:59 pm

Perfect,
Just maybe Cyclic load (Dynamic force) and Creep (Temprature cahnge)

Reply
Chris Hall
9/2/2021 12:45:12 am

Thanks, I agree.


Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Chris Hall

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Categories

    All
    Boundary Conditions
    FEA Tips And Tricks
    Modal
    News
    Nonlinear
    Oddball
    Top Ten

    Archives

    May 2023
    August 2022
    May 2022
    September 2021
    August 2021
    June 2021
    February 2020

HOME

SERVICES

PROJECTS

FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS

BLOG

​
​FAQs

​CONTACT


​Tel +44 (0)114 240 1422

© COPYRIGHT 2023 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Value Design Ltd
  • Services
  • Projects
  • Finite Element Analysis
    • Introduction to Basic FEA
    • Units
    • Co-ordinate Systems
    • FEA Procedure
    • Defining Objectives
    • Stress Concentration
    • Geometry import / clean up
    • Meshing
    • Material Properties
    • Boundary Conditions
    • Solvers
    • Investigating FEA Results
    • Reporting
    • Stress Theories
    • Cantilever Beam Worked Example
    • Pressure Vessel Worked Example
    • Shaft in Torsion Worked Example
    • Buckling Worked Example
    • Bearing (Contact) Worked Example
    • Non Linear Material Worked Example
    • Portal Frame Worked Example
  • BLOG
  • FAQ
    • What is FEA?
    • How much does FEA cost?
    • Should I de-feature CAD geometry prior to FEA?
    • What information should I send to you for an FEA quotation?
  • CONTACT